About Us

Frank Slaughter Insurance Agency, Inc. is celebrating its 57th anniversary, serving Sumter and surrounding counties.  The Independent agency was established in 1964 by Frank Slaughter, a life-long Sumter resident.  FSI was created to serve the community with honesty and integrity and strives to always practice the, “Golden Rule”.   In 1995, Frank retired and sold the business to his son, Sam, who’d worked alongside his father for 25 years.  In April of 2017, Sam retired as well, and FSI was purchased by his daughter, Angela Taylor, a 25-year veteran of the industry.   FSI is very active in the community and tries to give back to the community that has supported it.

Being an Independent, Trusted Choice agency, Frank Slaughter Insurance is committed to treating you as a person, not a policy.  With complimentary insurance reviews, FSI can make certain you are protected while locating potential savings with quality insurance companies.  “We are able to save most customers money and provide more coverage, especially those coming to us from a ‘1-800 insurance carrier,’” states Angela, owner.  “We strive to keep up with industry changes.  Being an Independent agency allows us to offer a selection of companies for home, auto, recreational items and business.  We offer exceptional service and options for our customers.”

FSI believes in prompt, courteous service on a personal level.  As Frank used to tell his grandchildren, “Anything worth doing is worth doing well,” and we take great pride in our work.  You will always speak to a licensed staff member, and appointments are not required.  The staff has over 65 years of combined insurance experience as well as a personal stake in the success of the community in which they work, live and play.  Call (352)748-2221 for an insurance review to see the options and savings available to you.

Please complete the form below for a quote.

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Frank Slaughter Insurance Agency, Inc is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Christopher S.

Frank Slaughter Insurance and have always had great service from Angela Taylor and her staff. If you are looking for great customer service this is the place for you!

Ann W.

Angela and team are helpful, honest and fair. They are a great group of people to work with for all of your insurance needs.

Rita C.


Family owned buisness. When your current policy is ending, they will shop for the best and most affordable policy given your situation. They strive to make obtaining insurance as painless as possible.

Bridget S.

Highly recommend for all of your insurance needs. Great customer service, very knowledgeable staff, and when you call you get to talk to an actual person, not 10 min of computer prompts!!